Skip to Content

So Long, Fair Whale

Six O'Matic

Länge: 03:50

Hochgeladen am: 14.06.2018 17:25 | PA

Driving rock with soaring synths.

  • Song
  • Songwriting: 7.0
  • Arrangement: 8.0
  • Performance: 7.0
  • Sound
  • Frequenzbild: 7.0
  • Räumlichkeit: 8.0
  • Dynamik: 8.0
  • Lautstärkeverhältnisse: 7.0

Bewertung HOFA
  • Song
  • Songwriting: 3
  • Arrangement: 3
  • Performance: 4
  • Sound
  • Frequenzbild: 3
  • Räumlichkeit: 4
  • Dynamik: 3
  • Lautstärkeverhältnisse: 3
Analyse HOFA

Songwriting & Arrangement:

This song is an instrumental track based in the rock genre. Although the harmonic structure works for the song we miss a clear melodie to speak of a real song. The chords are alright but are pretty standard. Therefore, we suggest to add a bit of a variety like major and minor changes.

Recording / Performance:

From a technical point of view the recordings of your song are quite good. No signal is overdriven and no annoying noises landed on the recording - very nice. All instruments are "tight" and played to the beat. This is an important aspect that significantly influences the quality of the song.


We noticed that the reverb you used is not quite optimal for the song. In this case you have used relatively much reverb, which makes the instruments seem a little too indirect. In future, be careful not to place too much emphasis on reverb so that the instruments sound more direct. You could also make the frequency response of your mix more natural - we can still hear potential here. This may be due to unmusical volumes of individual tracks, as well as corresponding EQing. We noticed that your mix has been limited quite heavily. This severely limits the dynamics of the song and leads to artifacts and a somewhat unnatural, undynamic sound. In the future you should use the limiter a bit more subtley to avoid damaging the musical dynamics of the song.

The following screenshot shows a picture of a spectral analyser where you see the frequency curves of your mix. The lower curve describes the average energy level, whereas the upper curve shows the corresponding peak hold per band:


Ø 4.6


Stimmen wurden abgegeben.


Hier gelten die Community-Regeln, wie sie in der Netiquette festgehalten sind.

(( comment.username )) hat am (( comment.datetime )) eine Bewertung mit (( comment.avg_score | round)) Punkten abgegeben.
(( comment.username )) schrieb am (( comment.datetime ))
  • Song
  • Songwriting: (( comment.songwriting ))
  • Arrangement: (( comment.arrangement ))
  • Performance: (( comment.performance ))
  • Sound
  • Frequenzbild: (( comment.frequencies ))
  • Räumlichkeit: (( comment.spaciality ))
  • Dynamik: (( comment.dynamics ))
  • Lautstärkeverhältnisse: (( comment.loudness ))

(( comment.content ))

Hier gelten die Community-Regeln, wie sie in der Netiquette festgehalten sind.

(( child.username )) antwortete am (( child.datetime ))

(( child.content ))

Mehr Kommentare anzeigen